In business, challenges can arise unexpectedly, putting companies at risk. Financial struggles can lead owners to a crucial decision: to seek relief through insolvency law or to navigate their difficulties alone. While Insolvency Law and Liquidation can offer significant advantages, many business owners hesitate to consider these options. This reluctance often stems from misunderstandings and deeply rooted misconceptions.
In this article, we will explore the reasons behind this apprehension, debunk common myths, and highlight the benefits of understanding and utilising insolvency law as a pathway to recovery. Benefits like SARS and outstanding taxes, CCMA and Employees, Rental and contractual agreements and outstanding Creditors.
The Reality of Insolvency Law
Insolvency law functions as a protective mechanism for businesses facing serious financial troubles. Its primary goal is to provide guidance and structure during critical times, allowing business owners to consider various options that could lead to recovery and sustainability.
Many people associate insolvency law strictly with the concept of Liquidation. However, it encompasses various strategies aimed at rescuing struggling businesses. For example, Business Rescue, which includes the opportunity for a company to enter info a voluntary arrangement with creditors and suppliers, can permit a business to re-organise its debts and continue operating. This can be a lifeline, enabling companies to keep their employees and protect stakeholder interests.
Despite these potential benefits, the fear of Liquidation remains a common barrier to seeking help. Business owners may cling to the idea that asking for assistance equates to defeat, missing out on opportunities for renewal and growth.
Debunking the Myths: Embrace Insolvency Law and Liquidation
It is essential to understand that seeking help through insolvency law does not indicate a lack of ability. In fact, being proactive in addressing financial difficulties is a sign of strong leadership. For instance, a 2020 survey found that 62% of business leaders who sought insolvency assistance reported feeling more empowered to make informed decisions afterward.
Additionally, Liquidation does not always signify a business's end. In circumstances where a company enters Liquidation, it can still sell valuable assets and potentially re-emerge in a more resilient form. Changing the narrative from failure to potential rebirth can encourage more business owners to reconsider their stance toward insolvency.
Financial Mismanagement vs. Unforeseen Circumstances
Don't equate financial struggles with personal failure, which can hinder the willingness to explore insolvency options. It is vital to recognise that financial distress can arise from factors outside their control, such as economic downturns or sudden shifts in demand.
For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic, over 30% of small businesses reported significant revenue declines, demonstrating that external circumstances can heavily impact even established firms. Understanding the broader economic landscape can encourage leaders to seek help rather than attributing their struggles solely to personal shortcomings.
The Fear of Personal Liability
The potential for personal liability is another major concern among business owners. Many fear that engaging with insolvency law could jeopardise their personal assets. This concern often leads entrepreneurs to prolong decisions about seeking help, even when the business is in dire need.
The degree of personal risk hinges on the business structure. For instance, if a business is registered as a limited company, owners typically enjoy protection from personal liability regarding business debts. It is crucial for business owners to understand the implications of their specific business structure and seek clarity on personal liability during insolvency. As an example if personal surety was signed for Business Credit then the personal liability will apply regardless of Company structure.
Lack of Understanding of Available Options
A significant barrier to embracing insolvency law is a fundamental lack of awareness and owners do not fully understand the array of options available to them within the insolvency framework.
Having the right knowledge is essential for effective decision-making. Engaging with insolvency specialists can shed light on the various routes available, such as restructuring a company or opting for voluntary liquidation. Empowering themselves with knowledge enables business owners to take decisive actions instead of being paralysed by fear.
CCMA and Employees
The CCMA has no jurisdiction to consider the validity of a winding-up order. In the case of a final winding-up order being granted, an employee may lodge a claim of outstanding money with the Liquidators. Any claim brought by an employee to the CCMA would end upon the company or close corporation's final Liquidation.
In the event of a Company owning assets, these assets would be sold and the proceeds or realisation of these assets would be used to pay a percentage to creditor.s Employees are regarded as Preferential Creditors in a Liquidation and so would receive a large portion of the realisation of assets - if assets exist.
Where a company has no assets, the employees would not receive any percentage and their claim would be written off 100%.
SARS and Liquidation
The South African Revenue Services (SARS) are also regarded as a Preferential Creditor in a Company Liquidation.
Once a Liquidator is appointed, meetings are held with SARS to finalise outstanding tax returns and to determine what percentage of the realisation of assets in the company will be paid to SARS.
If the company has no assets then the amount owing to SARS will be written off.
However, if SARS can prove that the Company acted negligently, irresponsibly or fraudulently where the management of money is concerned, SARS can bring a personal liability case against members of the Company to recuperate outstanding tax and costs. This only really occurs in extreme situations where negligence is apparent. Otherwise Liquidation will result in outstanding tax either receiving a percentage of the realisation of assets or be written off if there are no assets in the Company.
Rental Agreements
Generally there is an insolvency clause in rental / contractual agreements which states that the rental or agreement will come to an end when Liquidation occurs. However, if this clause is not indicated in the contract then the rental generally comes to an end when notice is given by the Liquidator.
If the Liquidator does elect to terminate the agreement, the other contracting party cannot force the Liquidator to perform in terms of the agreement and instead has a monetary claim against the insolvent estate as a Concurrent Creditor.
Concurrent Creditors are last to receive any proceeds from the sale of assets. If there are no assets or proceeds are paid to Preferential, Secured and Unsecured Creditors then the Concurrent Creditors claims are written off.
Creditors and Suppliers
There are four distinct types of Creditors in a Liquidation:
1. Secured Creditors are Creditors holding security for their claims. Secured Creditors have a claim to a company's assets as security for a debt. They are given priority over Unsecured Creditors when a Company is Liquidated. These Creditors are the first to be paid from the sale of the assets that are used as security.
2. Preferent Creditors are Creditors who do not hold specific security for their claims, but rank above Unsecured Creditors. They are given priority over other Creditors during a Liquidation. They are paid from the general pool of assets before Unsecured Creditors. Preferential Creditors are paid in full if the asset pool is sufficient. If no assets exist in the Company, then they will receive no payment in a Liquidation.
Preferent Creditors include employees’ remuneration (up to a prescribed amount) and SARS.
3. Unsecured Creditors are paid after Secured and Preferential Creditors. Unsecured Creditors are often only partially repaid because their claims are dependent on the remaining assets. If there are no company assets, they do not receive payment for outstanding claims.
4. Concurrent Creditors are Unsecured Creditors who are paid last in a Liquidation process. They are paid after all other Creditors have been paid, and they may receive little to no payment.
The Role of Professional Guidance
Seeking professional guidance is vital for understanding the complexities and potential outcomes of managing insolvency.
Insolvency practitioners bring crucial insights and support throughout the process. Working with experienced advisers can yield tailored strategies that address specific challenges and allows you to embrace Insolvency Law and Liquidation to resolve issues with a struggling business. An expert can also help dispel myths and provide accurate assessments of the effects of pursuing insolvency assistance.
A Path Toward Recovery: Embracing Change
Business leaders should shift their perspective, viewing Liquidation not as defeat but as a strategic reset. They can learn from their experiences and, through proper restructuring, build businesses that are more resilient. Research shows that companies that undertake strategic changes during times of financial difficulty are 50% more likely to recover successfully.
Insolvency law is a valuable tool for recovery and demands a cultural shift in how it is perceived. Understanding that seeking help is a mark of resilience can encourage more business owners to take constructive action.
Considering Liquidating your Business? We have legal experts with 20 years experience that can guide you through the process. Our main aim is to be as informative as possible. Let's Chat.
If you require advice with regards to Sequestration, Voluntary Surrender, Business Liquidations, Insolvency, Bankruptcy or Credit Rehabilitation kindly contact SOLVENDI as follows:
National: 087 220 0710
Head Office: 010 880 7589
Email: consultations@solvendi.co.za
Website: www.solvendi.co.za
Comments